This is the tried and tested original Halifax Donair Sauce, originally created in Halifax by Peter Gamoulakos. I can taste no difference from what I remember growing up in Halifax, NS. The addition of Onion Powder is solely my own. I like the flavor the onion offers and works really well with items the sauce is used for.

There is some debate about whether evaporated or sweetened condensed milk should be used. A 1978 article from the Chronicle Herald states that sweetened condensed milk is the main ingredient, whereas Halifax Magazine, in an interview with Leo Gamoulakos, reports that the original sauce had 5 ingredients: evaporated milk, sugar, vinegar, garlic powder, and parsley. I gather that most shops use evaporated milk, at least in Halifax. But there are shops that use condensed or a mix of both. I wrote a Food For Thought article just on this and why the Original or Authentic version is made with Evaporated Milk and not Sweetened Condensed Milk.

Below is the store-bought version ingredient listing. I am not crazy about these, and you will taste a difference between homemade and store-bought, for sure. I forget which one now. But one of them was really bad. Tasted chemical like.

Donair Sauce Ingredients

The original sauce had 5 ingredients: evaporated milk, sugar, vinegar, garlic powder, and parsley. Commercial kinds, has added water and starch to increase volume and stability.

Mr. Donair INGREDIENTS

WATER, SUGAR, EVAPORATED MILK, POWDERED MILK, VINEGAR, MODIFIED CORNSTARCH, GARLIC POWDER, SODIUM BENZOATE.

Bonte INGREDIENTS

Water, sugar, whey powder, modified corn starch, canola oil, garlic powder, citric acid, xanthan gum, sodium benzoate, polysorbate 60, titanium dioxide. Contains: Milk

In any event, I suspect that the original sauce was Tzatziki. But it wasn’t well accepted at the time. So this was created to appeal to the taste buds of the people of Halifax. This became the famous Halifax Donair Sauce we love and recognize today. You can make this at home easily, and it’s the real thing, and definitely better than any store bought kind.

How long to refrigerate Donair Sauce

When first mixed and refrigerated, the Sauce can be used in as little as an hour. However, an overnight refrigeration is better for thickening. Before using, drain out the liquid that have settled at the bottom to eliminate any excess liquids that would otherwise thin out the Sauce. After this, you can bottle the Sauce or keep it in a Tupperware container and store in the fridge.

How Long does Donair Sauce Keep

I have kept this for over a month. In general, you will see it go to a yellow color before it goes bad, sort of smelling off. It lasts a very long time. Keep it covered and refrigerated. I’ve always used it up eventually so use your best judgment, however it does last unusually long.

Why is my donair sauce runny

You need to whisk the Milk & Sugar to incorporate air into the Evaporated Milk before the Vinegar is added.

Over mixing when the vinegar is added will result in a runny Sauce. About 12 turns or so is all that is needed while pouring in the Vinegar.

Liquid will accumulate at the bottom, gently move the Sauce to the side to drain out excess Liquid and stir the Sauce again. If the Liquid is not drained out, you will end up with runny sauce. Some do remix the Sauce, but this will give you a thinner Sauce. I always drain it out.

Donair Sauce Uses

There are plenty of other uses, some of which are listed below.