Deli Mayo delivers bold flavor with a perfectly balanced taste that works across countless dishes. Spread it on sandwiches, subs, and wraps, or serve it as a dip for fried fish, chicken nuggets, chicken fingers, and more. Mix in a few extra ingredients to create a creamy potato salad, or use it to make deviled eggs and egg salad sandwiches. This versatile sauce belongs on just about anything you’d find in a deli, which is exactly how Deli Mayo earned its name. One all-purpose deli sauce opens the door to endless possibilities in the kitchen.
Deli Mayo Ingredients
Hellmann’s Mayonnaise, French’s Yellow Mustard (or Dijon Mustard), Pickle Juice, White Sugar, Green Onion, Celery Salt, White Pepper, Onion Powder, and Garlic Powder.
How to make Deli Mayo
Throw all the ingredients together and mix well; that’s all there is to it!
Deli Dijonnaise
The Deli Mayo and all its variations all start with Dijonnaise and then build upon this.
- Dijonnaise: Dijonnaise is a 6:1 ratio of mayonnaise to Dijon mustard. This is a basic deli spread.
- Deli Mayo: We take the Dijonnaise and add to it pickle juice & sugar, green onion, celery salt, white pepper, garlic powder, and onion powder. This now becomes a secondary spread for deli-style sandwiches in the same style as the Lumberjack or Dagwood sandwiches. You can keep the mustard at the same level as in the dijonnaise or add more.
- Deli mayo variations: Add other ingredients to customize the flavor for deli-style favorites like potato salad, egg salad sandwiches, deviled eggs, dipping sauces, and condiment sauces for burgers, sausages, and hot dogs.
Variations
Customize the sauce for different sandwiches by adding a new ingredient or swapping out an existing one. You can also build on the sauce with extra ingredients to create flavorful spreads, dips, and sauces for other dishes.
Spicy Deli Mayo
For a spicy Deli Mayo, add in some chopped jalapeño or other hot peppers. Hot sauce may be added as well. Such as Sriracha or RedHot Buffalo Sauce.
Eggy Deli Mayo
Add about 1/8 tsp of black salt or more to taste. Optionally drop the celery salt by however much black salt is used. This is really good for deviled eggs or an egg salad sandwich.
Smokey Deli Mayo
Smoked paprika with or without a drop or two of liquid smoke can be added. Really good on burgers.
Sandwiches
A flavorful sauce that is really good on sandwiches, Kaiser rolls, subs, or oven subs and is very similar to the lumberjack spread. The below image is a Chicken Deli Trio Ovensub with Deli Mayo, incredibly delicious!
Ingredients
- 1/2 C Helmann's Mayo
- 2 Tbl Dijon Mustard - anywhere from 4 tsp to 2 Tbl
- 1 Tbl Pickle Juice
- 1 tsp Sugar
- 1 Stalk Green Onion - minced
- 1/2 tsp Celery Salt, White Pepper, Onion Powder, & Garlic Powder - each, 1/4 tsp to 1/2 tsp of any one or all of these, adjust to taste
Instructions
- Combine all ingredients together in a bowl and mix well. Cover and refrigerate. Adjust the flavors however you see fit.
Browse More Recipes!
Old Fashioned Turkey Sandwich
Old Fashioned Turkey Sandwich is just a classic and craveable all by itself. Sometimes nothing will do but this sandwich in…
Egg Salad Sandwich
This is my go-to recipe for Egg Salad sandwiches that may be familiar to a Tim Hortons Egg Salad Sandwich. You…
Fried Ham & Cheese Sandwich
Fried Ham & Cheese Sandwich on Buttered bread or Arby’s style on buttered and toasted buns. Either way, it’s a really…
Grilled Deluxe Burger Sandwich
The Grilled Deluxe Burger Sandwich made up the same way as the Grilled Cheeseburger Sandwich and using the same ingredients as…
Cream Cheese Toast
Cream Cheese Toast is a nice light lunch or snack to have and is made with toasted sourdough bread slathered with…